We're a brand new podcast! Please follow the show in your favorite podcast app, and leave a review!
What the Hype?!
What the Hype?!
What The Hype?! is the class you always wanted, but were never offered in school! Each week, a panel of pop culture junkies educate each other on today’s biggest books, shows, movies, and more. No matter your experience, there’s something for everyone. Total Noob? We'll educate you on why the fandom took off and what makes someone a true fan! Already an expert? We’ll just see about that! Our subsequent episodes will take you on a deep dive and really test your stan-hood! And, if you’re somewhere in the middle, teetering on the edge of fandom, we’ll show you What The Hype is all about! What The Hype?! is from the creators of MuggleCast (the original Harry Potter podcast diving deep into the books, movies, and Wizarding World fandom) and #Millennial (featuring pretend adulting and real talk about the Gen Y lifestyle)
Choose your favorite podcast player
What the Hype?!

What the Hype?!

What The Hype?! is the class you always wanted, but were never offered in school! Each week, a panel of pop culture junkies educate each other on today’s biggest books, shows, movies, and more. No matter your experience, there’s something for everyone. Total Noob? We'll educate you on why the fandom took off and what makes someone a true fan! Already an expert? We’ll just see about that! Our subsequent episodes will take you on a deep dive and really test your stan-hood! And, if you’re somewhere in the middle, teetering on the edge of fandom, we’ll show you What The Hype is all about!

What The Hype?! is from the creators of MuggleCast (the original Harry Potter podcast diving deep into the books, movies, and Wizarding World fandom) and #Millennial (featuring pretend adulting and real talk about the Gen Y lifestyle)

Play Latest Episode

Recent Episodes

Oct. 13, 2025

Ghosts, Slashers & the Human Mind: What's the Hype About Fear?

It’s spooky season, and this week we're getting real about what scares us most. From creepy childhood stories to jump scares we’ll never forgive, we’re breaking down why being scared is actually… kind of fun. Join Laura, Eric...
Oct. 6, 2025

Reacting to Taylor Swift’s ‘The Life of a Showgirl’ (ALBUM REVIEW)

Grab your sequins and feather boas and prepare to take a dive into Taylor Swift’s ‘The Life of a Showgirl’! On this episode of What the Hype, Pam is joined by her brother (and fellow Swiftie), Sergio to offer up our immediate...
Sept. 29, 2025

Back to Hawkins: Stranger Things Season 1 & 2 Breakdown

We’re heading back to Hawkins! In this episode, we revisit the first two seasons of Stranger Things —from Demogorgons and the Upside Down to Eggo waffles and Steve Harrington’s hair. Join us as we recap the biggest twists, ch...
Sept. 23, 2025

Outlander Prequel Deep Dive - Episodes 1-6: Love, Lies & Time Travel

Join Pam and Laura as they recap and react to the first 6 episodes of 'Outlander: Blood of My Blood' on Starz. So far, we're FULL of questions and excitement about the connections being made to the main 'Outlander' series. Ho...
Sept. 15, 2025

2025 Emmy Awards Highlights: Surprises, Trends & Must-See Moments

Join Pam and Laura on this week’s episode of What the Hype as we recap the 2025 Emmy Awards. What were the most memorable moments of the night and who won big are discussed. Plus, the hosts talk favorites among the series nom...
Sept. 8, 2025

Wednesday Season 2 Part 2 Explained: Endings, Clues & What’s Next

Hold onto your right hand because Laura, Pam and Micah are back at Nevermore breaking down all of the twists and turns of Season 2 of Netflix’s Wednesday. From heart-stopping twists worthy of The Tell-Tale Heart to revelation...

About the Hosts

Andrew Sims

Host, Editor

Andrew is based in Nevada and began podcasting when he founded MuggleCast in 2005. In addition to full time podcast work and co-hosting #Millennial Podcast with Laura, Andrew created a Patreon online course and Patreon book to help other creators master Patreon. Andrew obsesses over Bruce Springsteen, video games, dogs, and nature.

Laura Tee

Host

Laura was bitten by the podcasting bug in 2006 when she first joined MuggleCast. Podcasting stuck with her through living abroad in Costa Rica (pura vida, mae) and graduate school in New York City. Outside of MuggleCast, Laura enjoys all things linguistics and hosts the current affairs podcast #Millennial alongside Andrew. She loves her hometown of Atlanta, where she lives with her boyfriend and adorable dog, Canela.

Eric James

Host

Eric is originally from Reading, Pennsylvania, and is a lover of popular media, with their hands in several podcast pies. When not co-hosting or editing MuggleCast, editing the bimonthly Improvised Star Trek podcast, or producing the Human Resources advice podcast “HR unConfidential,” Eric enjoys exploring Chicago, where they have lived since 2008.

Micah Tannenbaum

Host

Micah is a New York native whose MuggleCast journey began when he reached out to Andrew about recording weekly news segments. It wasn’t long before he was invited to be a regular host on the show. Micah continues to listen, analyze, and defend Aberforth’s goat, while also podcasting about pop culture here on What the Hype?!. In the Muggle world, Micah trades Quidditch for basketball in his day-to-day job.

Pamela Gocobachi

Host

Pam is a Bay Area native and an entertainment journalist with a deep love for all things pop culture. When she’s not writing or podcasting you can often find her obsessing over new music finds, drinking coffee like it’s her job, or doting over her dog Jasper.

Reviews

Great show

"I was so excited to see a new show from hosts I’ve loved listening to for nearly 20 years. Can’t wait for more new episodes! I’m lagging behind in keeping up with all the new and new-ish tv shows, et…"

LostHobbitLass | June 11, 2024

Excellent

"Really enjoyed these first couple of episodes and just know that this will be an excellent show. After listening to these hosts for literal decades I just know this show will continue to keep the bar…"

Renee_bbe | June 11, 2024

Off to a wonderful start!

"So thrilled to hear about a new podcast for this lovely crew! Enjoyed the first couple episodes, and can’t wait to see what comes next!"

msaavava | June 8, 2024

Delightful breath of fresh air

"After listening to these hosts other show Mugglecast for 19 years, so thrilled to hear their takes on more general pop culture phenomenon with such a great panel format."

Kyle Mahaney | June 8, 2024

Binging the first episodes this weekend

"I love listening to these nerds talk about politics and Harry Potter, so I’m very excited to get more pop culture from them! I’ll probably play these episodes drunk this weekend and then play them ag…"

SeanyFam | June 7, 2024

Will follow these hosts forever…

"I was BEYOND excited when this podcast was announced! All of the hosts are wonderful and I’m really looking forward to hearing them cover all things pop culture. I’m also really excited about learnin…"

Morgan_JJ | June 7, 2024

Highly recommend!

"So excited for this podcast! It’s so fun to have another show with these hosts, it always feels like listening to friends. They really do their research, I love listening to their hot takes and conne…"

ZazzyG19 | June 13, 2024

Love you guys!

"I was so surprised to hear my favorite hosts started a new podcast! Just listened to the Bridgerton and The Boys episodes and y’all have convinced me to give both shows a chance!"

dannyjmt | June 14, 2024

For all the fandoms

"I have enjoyed these hosts so much over the years through Mugglecast and Millenial. I’m so excited that they’ll have the space to cover literally anything and everything pop culture related because I…"

Lindseyhopes | June 17, 2024

So much fun

"I don’t always follow pop culture trends for one reason or another but don’t mind getting filled in on things I’m not a part of. This group of people always put together top notch content and have fu…"

Raevyn Lynn | June 17, 2024